I think the OP is referring to this platform?
https://youtu.be/w6fn0QfO9fg
https://www.brownells.com/.aspx/bapid=700/ClientPage/brownells-brn-180
This?
Might make for a cool mac conversion upper since you don't need the buffer tube....
... as nothing beats the standard DI gas system.
a heavy walled gas tube for use with a 20" HBAR upper?
I ordered one in February 2019 when Brownells first offered them. The first upper was a difficult fit to the front pin, very tight. That upper would short stroke every round fired.
It would eject the empties, and not chamber a new round. That upper went back to Brownells, and in a few weeks I received a new upper.
My second upper fit, and functioned perfectly to the point the front hand guard was to hot to hold. I ordered a pack of seven, Squid Grip rubber M-Lok inserts from Troy industries and press them on to the hand guard.
I also ordered 15 slot picatinny rails for the front of the hand guard and found out that the mounting screws once installed are to long to allow the barrel to be inserted through the hand guard. I filed the screws flush to the inner mount brackets and the barrel slid through and locked up fine.
I had my gun shop install a Franklin Armory binary firing system III to my Palmetto State Armory lower. The BRN-180 upper works fantastic on that lower.
I'm very happy with this upper and lower.
Nick
Thank you for the feedback.
I've been using Brownells for about 25 years, as have many people in our area. On the extremely rare occasion that an item, or order, isn't right, they quickly remedy the problem. They are my 1st choice for parts and supplies.
https://www.brownells.com/.aspx/bapid=700/ClientPage/brownells-brn-180
This?
Might make for a cool mac conversion upper since you don't need the buffer tube....
That would require major rework for both the Max-11/15-S.A.B.R.E. style or Tenko adapter systems. The Max-11/Max-11/15-Utimac system uses a standard AR-15/M16 carrier. The Brownell upper's carrier is different and would require a custom designed sear catch. The Tenko adapter is also based on a M16 carrier upper that requires a sear trip surface. The Brownell's upper doesn't have that sear trip surface. So the Brownell's upper can't be used with a M16 or the Tenko adapter in auto. So without addressing these issues neither Mac style rifle caliber system will function with the Brownell's upper system.
Scott