I guess we haven't beat this horse to death... :dunno
I suspect most people who've never used both an OEM type strap and a rigid fore grip for a period of time won't have a clear feel for which is "better" and in this case, "better" is subjective. I've put in many thousands of rounds down range using both, and I prefer a rigid type grip when using the OEM upper. I like K grips on most of my weapons so I'm probably biased toward them.
The original fat MACs used a surplus M1 Garand sling, cut and sewn up to fit the hanger. It had to be cheap and effective to stay in line with the gun's cost, and it served both purposes well. I've shot all MAC variants with the OEM strap using several gripping methods and it offers much better control than a typical weak hand over strong hand grip most people use when shooting pistols.
In a close quarters, rapid deployment type of use for something like dignitary protection details, I'm betting there isn't time to correctly grasp and use the strap when the SHTF. One the other hand, a rigid rip could make covert concealment of the weapon more difficult. You give up one for the other.
For weekend warriors like us, I think most people will enjoy the extra control a rigid fore grip gives them over muzzle climb, but whatever floats your boat. I understand many owners enjoy their MACs in OEM configuration and there's much to be said for that. For casual high speed plinking or for use in competition, I'd rather use a rigid fore grip. That's my choice.
I've never felt the OEM strap was inherently dangerous. As with any weapon, situational awareness and muzzle discipline are imperative.
M1A.... said:
:lol:lol I love it!! You're gonna fit right in!!!! :lol:lol
He fit right in for a total of two days before he was banned.
__________________
If you think health care is expensive now, wait until you see what it costs when it's free! -P.J. O'Rourke